SUNSET (2018) – Review

Here’s something for those few who don’t want to see (or can’t get tickets to) the big superhero slugfest that’s on most of this country’s movie screens. It’s a drama set in a turbulent time in another country. It’s full of lush intricate costumes and lavish estates because it’s set near the end of a genteel, refined era, just before the dawning of the coarse, mechanized, violent modern age. Perhaps that’s the reason for the English title: SUNSET.

After a title card telling us about the 1913 rivalry between Budapest and Vienna, the camera is locked on the listless face of an aristocratic young woman, perhaps in her early twenties being served at a clothes store. After trying on several fancy decorative hats, she announces that she’s actually there in search of a job. The flustered floor manager Zelma (Evelin Dobos) takes her to the supervisor’s office. He, Mr. Brill (Vlad Ivanov) is shocked to see that the applicant (who has arrived with several hat designs) is Irisz Leiter (Juli Jakab) namesake of the store’s original owners (Leiter’s is quite the exclusive ladies’ shop, about to celebrate 30 years), the only survivor of the fire that claimed her parents, leading to the purchase of the place by Brill. Irisz wants no special treatment, only the chance to escape her foster home and work at her family’s business. Brill cannot offer a job but insists she stay overnight at a nearby boarding house for the shop’s staff. Late that night, she is awakened by an intruder, a crazed stableman named Gaspar (Levente Molnar) who mumbles that she barely resembles her brother, before the landlord chases him away. Irisz was not aware of any sibling. Brill dismisses the news, but Irisz makes this quest her number one priority. Eventually, she is hired by the shop, but her evenings are spent in pursuit of this “phantom brother”. As her search leads her into a dangerous part of town Irisz learns that he is a wanted man who may be organizing a revolt against the upper classes. Can she find him before those deadly plans are carried out?

In his follow-up to the Oscar-winning SON OF SAUL director and co-writer (along with Clara Royer and Matthieu Taponier) utilizes several themes and techniques from that earlier work but without the impact or an equally compelling story. For much of the film’s running time, the camera is either trained on Irisz or seems to be just over the shoulder almost giving us a point-of-view (POV) from the character’s perspective. While it worked for Saul in that film, here it just gives an extra bit of disorientation and proves frustrating and distracting during the story’s few action sequences. We wonder, “What’s that noise? Where is it coming from? Stay on that person. Why are we looking there?”. It doesn’t help that the main character is so passive. Jakab seems to have the same dead-eyed stare through the whole languid two-plus hours, not even crying out as she’s nearly ravaged twice. It’s a flawed directorial choice that distances us from her character and the drama. The filmmaker may be trying to make a statement about the class system, but its themes are diluted by a third act that invokes the twist of FIGHT CLUB (amongst other superior works). Those unfamiliar with Hungary in the early 20th century will have many questions. Are the angry lower-class mobs inspired by the Russian revolt? Are these events directly connected to the start of the first World War? Ultimately we’re tasked with the “heavy lifting” due to the muddled script and storytelling style. The production artists truly put us in that time period (horse carriages and early autos), but it’s not enough to make SUNSET enlightening to anyone other than Eastern European history buffs and millinery fans (the hats are pretty wild, though).


1 Out of 5


SUNSET opens everywhere and screens exclusively in the St. Louis area at Landmark’s Plaza Frontenac Cinemas

SON OF SAUL – The Review

sonofsaul

Once again, a gifted film maker brings us a new work inspired by the last great global conflict, World War II. And like many other previous films, this is set in the concentration camps, pehraps the most famous of them all, Auschwitz. It is a tale of horror and redemption, sacrifice and suffering. Yes, movie goers have seen countless stories, in documentaries and docu-dramas. So, just what sets this one apart, why has it become the Oscar front-runner for Best Foreign Language Film? For one thing, the movie hails from Hungary, a fresh perspective from a revitalized film community. Plus, the imaginative and innovative way the story is told coupled with an riveting performance at its center accounts for the power reactions to SON OF SAUL.

A brief written prologue expalins the function of the Sonderkommando, Jewish prisoners tasked with keeping the camps running smoothly for the Nazi officers. They live as long as they continue being useful, but they too will be eliminated eventually. The film centers on one of these men who rush about: Saul (Geza Rohrig). In the opening sequence he and his co-workers (their tattered jackets marked on the back with a red “X”), hurriedly usher in a new batch of prisoners, helping them disrobe before the mandatory “shower”. The loud speakers telling them to be quick or else their soup will get cold. As the massive shower doors clang shut, Saul gathers the coats, clothes, and suitcases. After the screaming and the pounding of the walls finish, the door opens, and Saul’s crew gathers up the bodies (the guards only refer to them as “pieces”). But everone is soon shocked to hear one of the bodies coughing. A boy of eight or nine years somehow survived the gas. Saul is the most surprised as this miracle has touched what is left of his abused soul. The relief is brief as one of the “medical supervsiors” snuffs out the lad’s life. But Saul now has a mission: this boy (who Saul believes could be his son) will not join the others in the ovens. Risking his life, Saul will locate a rabbi who will say the Kaddish over “his son” and give him a proper burial. Over the next two days Saul sneaks past cruel guards, joins a work crew, and distributes countless bribes in the quest to restore his dignity and humanity.

Director Laszlo Nemes made several stylistic decisions which invigorate the often familiar historical settings. Rather than going for an epic, widescreen image, he has instead decides to frame the action and drama within an almost square box, reminicent of last year’s dramatic thriller MOMMY. That film was presented in an 1:1 aspect ratio, while Saul is in the slighter larger 1.37:1, and unlike the earlier film the image never goes wide for effect or whimsical effect. This heightens the immediacy and intimacy of the story, allowing us to zero in on Saul himself. The camera is often in POV (point of view) mode as we see the action along with him. For most of the time, the camera encircles Saul, right on his back, flanking his shoulder. tight on his face almost like a flitting moth, darting from side to side. The truly places us at the center of things,as we hear the danger (shots, screaming) before it is in view, as Saul searches for the source. It can be a tad claustrophobic, but it produces an immersive feeling better than most 3 D film experiences.

All the film flourishes would be for naught without the compelling work by Rohrig at the story’s center as Saul. When we first meet him, Saul is merely a mindless drone, his heavy sad eyes dart to the ground when his captors bark out orders, until his inner program prompts him into the robotic rituals that make prolong his life. But with the boy upsets the routine by defeating the deadly gas, a light flickers in Saul’s eyes. Rohrig shows us his amazement that evil was thwarted, for a too brief time. From there he is pure determination, confounding his captors and co-workers. Saul is a man trudging through a nightmare, who suddenly slapped awake. He refuses to be distracted, even by a fleeting offer of physical contact from a female prisoner. The entire supporting cast is excellent, along with the recreation of the crumbling camps. All these elements contribute to make SON OF SAUL a powerful, unforgettable motion picture.

4.5 Out of 5

SON OF SAUL opens everywhere and screens exclusively in the St. Louis area at Landmark’s Plaza Frontenac Cinemas

SONY-SSOS-01_101315

Watch The Trailer For SON OF SAUL

SONY-SSOS-01_101315

Sony Pictures Classics has released the US trailer and poster for SON OF SAUL, opening in NY & LA on December 18th, followed by more theaters.

October 1944, Auschwitz-Birkenau.

Saul Ausländer is a Hungarian member of the Sonderkommando, the group of Jewish prisoners isolated from the camp and forced to assist the Nazis in the machinery of large-scale extermination.

While working in one of the crematoriums, Saul discovers the body of a boy he takes for his son.

As the Sonderkommando plans a rebellion, Saul decides to carry out an impossible task: save the child’s body from the flames, find a rabbi to recite the mourner’s Kaddish and offer the boy a proper burial.

son of saul 12

Director László Nemes’ film is Hungary’s official selection for the Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film.

His first feature, Nemes spent the last five years bringing this project to fruition.

Director László Nemes and Géza Röhrig Photo by Ildi Hermann, Courtesy of Sony Pictures Classics
Director László Nemes and Géza Röhrig
Photo by Ildi Hermann, Courtesy of Sony Pictures Classics

When asked where he came up with the idea for the film, the director said:

“When we were making A londoni férfi (The Man from London), in Bastia, the shoot was interrupted for a week and in a bookstore I found a book of eyewitness accounts published by the Shoah Memorial called Des Voix sous la cendre (Voices from beneath the Ashes), also known as “The scrolls of Auschwitz.” It’s a book of texts written by former Sonderkommando members from the extermination camps, who had buried and hidden their written testimonies before the rebellion in 1944. The actual documents were found years later. They describe their daily tasks, how the work was organized, the rules by which the camp was run and Jews exterminated, as well as how they put together a certain form of resistance.”

SON OF SAUL was the 2015 Cannes Film Festival’s Grand Prix winner.

son of saul 11