THE WOMEN ON THE 6TH FLOOR – The Review

 THE WOMEN ON THE 6TH FLOOR is a new period comedy/ drama from France that surprisingly has much in common with one of 2011’s American blockbusters, THE HELP. Both films are set in the societal upheaval of the early 1960s and both concern the travails of domestic workers and their employers. While the US version was tied to the civil rights movement ( with literally life and death at stake ), the French story is more concerned with social class structure along with a second chance romance. Still both films have a great deal of empathy for the sometimes invisible ” hired help”.

Jean Louis ( Fabrice Luchini) is a successful investment consultant at his old, established family banking firm in 1960’s Paris. He and his status-seeking socialite wife, Suzanne ( Sandrine Kiberlain ) and two spoiled preteen sons ( usually away at an exclusive boarding school ) reside in a large downtown apartment complex. Living above Jean Louis’s opulent apartment that encompasses the entire level are the Spanish born maids who work in the different households. These are the women of the sixth floor who each live almost in squalor, in tiny single rooms and must share one bathroom and a communal sink. One day Jean Louis’s French maid of many years finally quits after another clash with Suzanne. This occurs around the time of the arrival of Maria ( Natalia Verbeke ) a lovely young woman from Toledo who is soon seeking domestic help employment. Jean Louis hires Maria and is charmed by her and her other sixth floor friends ( one is a Daily Worker reading radical, another is deeply religious, one must escape an abusive husband, while another is out to snare a hubby ). His interactions with the ladies rekindle his zest for life after his soul had become deadened by his stale upper class routine. Finally Jean Louis must decide if he will stay on the path that his forefathers have traveled or defy convention and fully join Maria’s world.

The story of cultural and class romance has been explored in many different media ( the BBC-TV series ” Upstairs, Downstairs ” first springs to mind ). Everything here hinges on whether the film makers provide a fresh spin on this subject. I’d have to say that the results here are fairly predictable and a bit condescending. Luchini is the old stick in the mud business guy ( if this were an American film he’d be a WASP ). The breakfast egg fanaticism gives him that anal-retentive extra edge. His wife is a cold shrew only interested in impressing the neighbors, and is never really given the chance to change. Plus the sons are coarse, bullying jerks. Verbeke’s Maria is almost a sensual Mary Poppins who appears to awake the sleeping Jean Louis. She and her “sisters” are the earthy, passionate ethnics that will teach these dullards how to live. They’re each archetypes more than real people. The main problem with the film is the tentative relationship at its center. We can easily understand why Jean Louis falls for the spunky, beautiful, much-younger Maria, but it’s difficult to understand her attraction to him ( yeah, he’s wealthy and becomes more caring, but she deserves more ). The 60’s fashions and settings are well executed, but the final scenes seem hurriedly cobbled together. THE WOMEN ON THE 6TH FLOOR is a sweet-natured film full of good intentions that doesn’t succeed in bringing anything new in the clash between the classes.

Overall Rating: Two Out of Five Stars