Tribeca Review: ‘Moon’

Just a few hours ago Scott posted a blog asking why Moon is not getting a wide release, which you can view HERE. I completely understand why but I refrained from commenting so that I can save it all for this review. So while this technically is my review for the film, it is also my answer to Scott’s question.

Let me start by saying Moon is a fantastic film. Sam Rockwell gives an amazing performance, as usual. The story is well crafted and the direction by Duncan Jones is stellar. The special effects are incredible. This by no means looks like a low budget film, well low budget in Hollywood terms. So in summation, it is a brilliantly crafted science fiction based character study with great special effects and an awesome cast that all give great performances. However, I do not believe Sony has faith in it. They obviously trust it enough to purchase the film and agree to distribute it in some markets, but Sony will only dump it in the 2 big smart artsy indie markets. And here’s why†¦

The story is well crafted. I just said that as praise but Sony may look at it and believe the story is too complicated. While I understand the film, and almost everyone will if you pay attention, there are unexplained moments that only make sense after time passes by on screen. It is not a straightforward narrative. In fact, I overheard some critics in the bathroom after my screening saying that they were confused by the film. (I won’t name any names but I am looking at you Mr. Brown shoes with one shoelace untied) I as surprised by this, because in all honesty, the story makes perfect sense and is very well told. You just have to pay attention and possibly put a tiny bit of thought into it. Gasp. Think while watching a movie, that is preposterous.

Well, for the non-thinkers, this film still has a lot going for it. Sam Rockwell is a big part of that. I have been a huge fan of his work ever since I saw Confessions of a Dangerous Mind. I have seen some of his earlier work but that film really stood out for me and I have kept an eye on him ever since. Even if I do not fully enjoy the film, Rockwell does not fail to entertain. He can give a great comedic performance and with a turn of the switch induce hear wrenching emotion. In Moon, he delivers both, sometimes in the very same scene. I must point out the scene of him dancing to “Walking on Sunshine† is brilliant on so many levels. I believe that if I “checked out† and was completely lost watching Moon for 90 minutes, I would still enjoy just watching Sam Rockwell perform. My only complaint is that there is not more humor in the beginning of the film since it may be a bit slow for some viewers, but I think a second viewing may change that. It is clear just from recollection that certain details hint towards the progression of the story and paying more attention to the details will bring a better understanding and possibly more humor to the first 20 or so minutes. Look at me, again telling people they have to think and pay attention. Well†¦the visuals are cool. That means there are pretty pictures on screen.

I am sure that Sony can edit a trailer for the film that makes it seem like an epic Sci-Fi adventure. They could sell it as a Sam Rockwell/Kevin Spacey vehicle, despite only getting to hear Spacey’s voice. And of course add some extra sci-fiey sound effects like futuristic beeps and a loud sweeping score to it. I actually commend Sony for not falsely marketing the film. However, they should have more faith in it and the US audience because the film really is great and needs to be seen.

4.75 out if 5 post-it notes on GERTY

Jerry Cavallaro – www.AreYouStuckLikeChuck.com