Review: ‘September Dawn’ on DVD

September Dawn (2006) was directed by Christopher Cain (Young Guns) and tells the story of the Mountain Meadows Massacre in Utah. This horrible event took place 151 years ago on September 11, 1857. As the films begins, the words “based on actual events” appears on the screen. I do not doubt so much the idea that this atrocious event occurred, however I do find myself staying objective to the details of how it occurred and by whose hands the acts were committed. I can only say, if this depiction is true to the facts, I feel it is important that the film was made. The story follows a wagon train of Christians from Missouri and Arkansas as they seek supplies and a place to rest from a settlement of Mormons along their trail.

According to the film, the governing members of the Mormon Church eventually ordered their militia known as the day-riders to engage the Native Americans they had deceived and befriended to massacre every man, woman and child of the wagon train party. The Native Americans quickly learn that they have been misled and abandon the massacre before it is completed. At this point, Brigham Young, played by Terence Stamp (The Limey), orders Jacob Samuelson, played by Jon Voight (National Treasure), by way of the prophet Joseph Smith to finish God’s work and kill the remaining survivors. I found this film equivalent to a Hallmark movie, but with lots of violence.

I understand the inclusion of a love story between a young Mormon boy and a young Christian girl within the script was likely done for audience appeal, but question whether it was appropriate. The subject matter alone I found difficult to watch at times simply because it is, at least in part, based on actual events. For those interested in movies which shed light on history, I do [cautiously] recommend this film. I do not claim to have an opinion either way of the Mormon Church, nor do I imply any knowledge of their beliefs. I feel that the burden of bias may lie negatively on the storyteller(s), but appreciate the need to convey a piece of history.

[rating:2/5]

DVD Features:

• Descendants: Remembering the Tragedy featurette
• True Events: A Historical Perspective featurette
• Previews